If there’s one debate that could power the National Grid using pure personality alone, it’s St Ives vs Godmanchester.
Not Manchester.
Not Godman’s Chester.
Godmanchester. And yes locals will correct you lovingly but firmly.
Here’s the truth nobody admits:
Both towns are amazing — they’re just amazing in different flavours.
St Ives energy:
• Riverside walk with coffee in hand
• Market day impulse buys and zero regrets
• “Let’s meet for brunch” culture
• The kind of town where 10 minutes becomes 90 and nobody cares
Godmanchester energy:
• Quiet-life goals without feeling remote
• Space for scooters, prams, dogs and sanity
• The feeling of “we’ve cracked this whole work–life balance thing”
• A park situation so strong it should have its own postcode
And here’s the plot twist:
Loads of people who live in Godmanchester still go to St Ives for brunch and hair appointments.
And loads of people who live in St Ives secretly say “if we ever wanted more space, we’d look at Godmanchester.”
It’s not rivalry — it’s mutual admiration with a side of light teasing.
And if you ever want to see both personalities collide in one moment?
Put a St Ives person and a Godmanchester person in the same car and ask where to park.
Friendship-ruining stuff.
For families, both are brilliant in different ways.
For couples, both are dangerously romantic on a sunny evening.
For commuters, both behave themselves on weekdays.
The real headline is this:
You can’t go wrong — the only mistake is trying to pick based on logic alone.
Sometimes the right town isn’t the one that looks best on paper —
it’s the one that feels like home when you walk through it.
If you’re thinking about moving in or out of either St Ives or Godmanchester, the Home Seller Insider – Cambridgeshire newsletter gives ridiculously useful, no-jargon breakdowns of local micro-markets (schools, buyers’ trends, what’s hot, what’s cooled off — all without the corporate waffle)








